17 Comments
User's avatar
Michael Dinga's avatar

I feel like you need an old black & white film from days long passed—maybe “Pride of the Yankees”? Or maybe “The Bingo Long Traveling All-Stars and Motor Kings” for the title alone. But which to take out? May have to turn it up to 11! And LET’S GO REDS!

Expand full comment
Jay Melnick's avatar

Bang the Drum Slowly was a big critic favorite that few movie goers saw. And, Cobb with all his warts w

Expand full comment
Ziva’s Mom's avatar

Thank you for including A League of Their Own on your list.

Expand full comment
A-Dub514's avatar

Bull Durham is hands down the #1. I can't find fault with your top 10. A League of Their Own is my daughter's favorite, and I grew up on repeated viewings of Bad News Bears (I'm 47). I'd maybe include '42'. Thank god you didn't add "Fever Pitch" to the list..... Anyhow Happy Opening Day and with 162 games to go the Cincinnati Reds still have a shot!

Expand full comment
Maryland's avatar

How could you not have "For Love of the Game". Top 3 BB movies ever

Expand full comment
Joe Manero's avatar

Pride of the Yankees?

Expand full comment
Kiroo Lioneaver's avatar

As a millenial, although films like "Field of Dreams," etc. are up there (along with "Eight Men Out") more recent entires (like 2011's "Moneyball," like 2003's "Fever Pitch," like (I know it's not a movie but a TV series, Fox's 2016 "Pitch") are also personally highly rated.

Expand full comment
Todd David's avatar

Oh Chris, no mention of Bang the Drum Slowly. Come on man, what are we even doing here????

Expand full comment
Margaret Graham's avatar

I saw my first baseball game at Fenway Park in 1948! It's such a great sport. I've never seen a baseball movie I did not like!

Expand full comment
Ian Mark Sirota's avatar

A big part of the baseball fan in me died when the Expos left Montreal in 2004.

Expand full comment
Mary Faye Randolph's avatar

Must read – The Church of Baseball by Ron Shelton about the making of Bull Durham.

Also Chris, how could you leave out Mr. 3000? Tony would be disappointed.

Expand full comment
Mary Faye Randolph's avatar

My friends say that if I was beautiful, promiscuous, and lived in a minor league town I’d be Annie Savoy.

Expand full comment
Tony Dahlman's avatar

I absolutely hate the "Did Dottie drop the ball on purpose?" debate. It is a much better story with Kit legitimately beating her big sister than it would be if we assume that Dottie let her win. The amount of people who make arguments for the worse storyline boggles my mind.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

I didn't know that was even a debate until years later. When I saw the movie as a kid, I thought it was obvious Dottie dropped the ball on purpose.

Expand full comment
Timothy Gutwald's avatar

Same. And who is right or wrong or which ending makes a better movie isn’t really the point of these sorts of debates. The point of debating this is to bond over a movie that you both watched and enjoyed.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

No Rookie of the Year? Blasphemy! But what would you take off this list?

The only movie I haven't seen is The Rookie, and I enjoy every movie listed.

I actually saw League of their Own in theatres when I was 7 years old and loved it. THERE'S NO CRYING IN BASEBALL is such an iconic quote.

Moneyball makes me laugh. It's an inspirational movie about a team that overcomes all the odds...to lose in the first round and never get close to a World Series.

I'm also partial to Little Big League (it came out when I was 9) and Trouble With the Curve. (combines my two favorite things- Clint Eastwood and the Atlanta Braves)

I can't find it on YouTube, but I love the scene in Woman of the Year where Katharine Hepburn learns about baseball.

Expand full comment
NovaJOR's avatar

This list is correct. Bull Durham fair and away #1. :-) Happy opening day.

Expand full comment